Stefano`s Ristorante in Pompton Plains

Delicious food and great service!

Excellent Italian pasta & seafood! Friendly and fun environment to bring a crowd.

Food was great, service was great, the only negative was our experience with a remark we heard the waitress Mary Lou say out loud to the receptionist , " Not another table for two".

Terrible. My girlfriend and I ordered two pasta dishes from here both where disgusting. The sauce tasted like Rago meatballs def store bought fake as hell, not even dogs would eat them. Please go somewhere elsa if you want quality food.

Great food very nice service nice outside seating head lots of people talk about it was VERY WORTH GOING TO

Dining surprise. Generous portions, delicious

Nice place. Good food. Enjoyed the pizza.

Excellent, fresh Italian food, and friendly, professional staff.

Food is ok. Several of the dishes were cold. Some of the fish served was very dry. Service is excellent. It is BYOB. Portions are very big.

Great people and great food Excellant calamari Loved the sausage with pepper and onions

Oh my goodness! Sooooi good Mango salad was outstanding They did not rush us even tho it was busy. Will be back.

We just had a very enjoyable meal. My wife had a table salad and I had a mesculine salad with goat cheese followed by an overstuffed for each of us. We sat outside on this lovely summer evening. Service was great and the cost was reasonable. We're looking forward to going back.

Nice place. Its a BYO. Food is awesome

Food was delicious except for the bread. Server was knowledgeable and friendly. Service was extremely slow.

The chicken Francese Is excellent I recommend it my wife had the Fettuccine Alfredo and also said was excellent recommend this place but make reservations if you want to sit in the restaurant

What a surprise! Driven past all the time and even gotten pizza next door but never had dinner. The specials and dinner was fabulous. Unique and delicious. Make sure to BYOB to enjoy with this hidden gem of a restaurant.

Great service, great food

Me and my wife decided to have dinner here. We had heard a lot of really nice things about Stefanos fine dining. We had the apetizer stuffed artichoke and it was absolutely the best stuffed artichoke I have ever had in my entire life. We also tried the hot and cold antapasto. And it was absolutely magnificent. The calamari was so juicy and so tender I felt like I was in a dream while I was eating it. But it was REAL. Me and my wife also decided to share a big entree of Seafood Malafemena. And it was absolutely to die for!!!!!!!!! The lobster was perfectly cooked the clams nice and tender. The flavor was unbelievable. Melt in your mouth a dream that feels so real the calamari was so flavorful and delicious. I can’t even explain in words how delicious this food is! It is absolutely unbelievable. I will definitely be back atleast 2 to 3 times per week now and nowhere else!!!! This is my 2 go place. And I inspire people to come to this place because the food is really delicious!

Had an excellent veal chop special, good service, well made food.

Food was good but it was kind of a strange start. After being seated for about 5 minutes - enough to get settled and have a glass of wine, one of the servers came over and was telling us the specials. Half way through (there were lots of them) the hostess came over and told him he needed to go to a different table...He said "sorry, I've been assigned to a different section. Lou will take care of you." Well, I guess Lou was never notified of the change. We waited at least another 10 minutes or so before she happened to be walking by and asked if we needed anything. She was great but why the first guy couldn't finish telling us the specials was kind of strange...Maybe the other table was waiting even longer or was more important. Not exactly the best way to treat a customer

Great food, the waiter was great, must go

Delicious specials, great service, BYOB, nice atmosphere!

Had my engagement party here for roughly 70 people. Everything was smooth from beginning to end. Owners were accommodating with our requests and answered all our questions. Serving staff was extremely kind and professional. Food was delicious, our guests really enjoyed it. Restaurant was very clean. We had a great time.

Food was goos but service was a bit slow. I would go back.

Great food and very pleasant staff and atmosphere!

Dinner was fantastic, don't miss out on the cannolis!

Had my nieces bridal shower was there. Great food!

I tried this place in the past with my friend and I am obsessed ever since. I like the great ambience and delicious dishes and drinks. Kudos.

Excellent, delicious, just perfect!

FOOD was good

Great food and service. Bring your own wine.

Never been disappointed,every meal is better than the last.

Is the only decent pizza around Wanaque Area.

Always delicious! Amazing pizza, dinners, cant go wrong with anything you have here. Not to mention, the place is absolutely spotless. There is something to be said about a family run business. This family truly takes pride in what they do. Stefanos is by far our favorite pizza place.

Italian food delicious, excellant service reasonable prices.

I will start by saying the only thing this place has going for them. The food is good. But there are tons of other restaurants in the area with better food, and more importantly, better service who don’t treat their customers like garbage. I’ve been here multiple time, but the last 2 times starting with the owners being insanely rude and unprofessional. For this reason alone, I will never be back. I was in the industry for 8 years and never in my life witnessed 2 more unprofessional and rude people in regards to how they treat their customers. It was my mistake for giving them a second chance. We’ll never be back.

Eating dinner here as we speak. They only have one server on for the whole room. The one bus boy/food runner is VERY rude. He literally gave my mom so much attitude and talked really nasty to her. We have been here for two hours and just got our salads. We will probably have to wait another hour for our entrees. Never coming back.

I love the food very much. Great BYOB restaurant, the best in the area.

Delicious dinner. Generous portions. Waitress knew the menu very well. We had a special appetizer, stuffed artichoke - really good. Courses came out slowly but were worth the wait. We'll be back!

Phenomenal food. Family own and operated. Always friendly and welcoming. Rice balls are definenity what gets us there each time.

We stumbled in here almost by accident. We were seated right away. Food was hot and tasty. Then we just sat. And sat. And sat. Took almost 10 minutes to have our plates cleared. Then another 10 to be asked if we wanted anything else. We said no. Then we just sat. And sat. And sat. 10 minutes later we finally had the check. Good food. Less than stellar service.

Wonderful food service, menu.

The food is okay but I’ve had multiple issues with catering orders and I just can’t use them again. Last issue was they lost my order so the catering wasn’t ready. I was late to my meeting as a result. There was no apology and they wouldn’t even admit that they lost the order despite the obvious. They were very rude about it and just kept saying they were busy. I still don’t understand why they accepted the order if they couldn’t handle it. Ultimately, they are too unreliable to use for important catering orders. Never again!!!

I had a great time with friends and colleagues at our Holiday party. The atmosphere is welcoming and relaxing. The food was delicious and the waiters were attentative and professional.

Love this place, BYOB,Food is fantastic, had lots of different meals off the menu along with the rest of my family and have never been disappointed, always get one pizza for the table, awesome thin crust and we get treated like family . The best cannoli’s around and we have had a party here that was just great , again love this place.

Awesome pizzas 👍

Food is decent here. The place got busy quick. We didn’t have any waiter issues but I can see they that they didn’t have enough staff working. The place is BYOB. The portions are big, but the prices were little steep in my opinion.

Cheese ravioli we're dellicious. Outdoor seating if desired.

Food here is great! Servers are very pleasant, and know the menu very well. Always a pleasant dining experience.